Practice portal › Laws of Motion › Friction: Blocks, Belts and Inclines

A heavy box is to be dragged along a rough horizontal floor. To do so, person A pushes it at an angle 30° from the horizontal and requires a minimum force F_A, while person B pulls the box at an angle 60° from the horizontal and needs minimum force F_B. If the coefficient of friction between the box and the floor is (√3)/5, the ratio (F_A)/(F_B) is

Asked in JEE Main Online 2014 · The least force, and the best angle to pull

Answer: (4) 2/(√3)

Step-by-step solution

Idea: pushing down at an angle presses the box into the floor and adds to the friction; pulling up at an angle lifts it and subtracts. That single sign is the whole difference.

A pushes down at 30°:

F_A cos 30°=μ(W+F_A sin 30°), so

F_A=(μ W)/(cos 30°-μ sin 30°)=(μ W)/((√3)/2-(√3)/5·1/2)=(μ W)/((2√3)/5).

B pulls up at 60°:

F_B cos 60°=μ(W-F_B sin 60°), so

F_B=(μ W)/(cos 60°+μ sin 60°)=(μ W)/(1/2+(√3)/5·(√3)/2)=(μ W)/(4/5).

Dividing, μ W cancels and the two denominators simply swap:

(F_A)/(F_B)=(4/5)/(2√3/5)=4/(2√3)=2/(√3)≈1.15.

So the pusher works about 15% harder — the everyday reason a box is easier to pull than to shove.

Why the other options are wrong

More Friction: Blocks, Belts and Inclines questionsAll Friction: Blocks, Belts and Inclines questions →

Reading this solution needs no sign-in. You only sign in to practise against the clock and keep your progress.

Practise this with a timer